International Health Tourism Intermediary

Weight loss & metabolic health

Abdominal and inguinal hernia: when surgery is recommended

Written byWM Health Editorial Team

7 min read

Key takeaways

  • A hernia is a bulge of tissue or bowel pushing through a weak spot in the abdominal wall, commonly in the groin, at the belly button or at an old surgical scar.
  • Surgery is the only treatment that permanently fixes a hernia, but a small hernia that causes no symptoms may sometimes be monitored instead.
  • Repair is usually advised when a hernia causes symptoms, to prevent it becoming stuck or strangulated, and for most umbilical hernias in adults.
  • A painful hernia that cannot be pushed back, or one that comes with vomiting or colour change of the skin, needs urgent medical help.
  • Extra weight raises the likelihood of hernias, and reaching a healthier weight before repair may be suggested for some people with obesity.

Discovering a lump in the groin or near the belly button can be unsettling, and many people immediately ask whether they will need an operation. Hernias are common, and while surgery is the only way to repair one permanently, not every hernia needs an operation immediately. This guide explains the main types of abdominal and groin hernia, how they are assessed, when repair is usually recommended and which warning signs mean you should seek help urgently.

What a hernia is

A hernia forms when a sac of the abdominal lining, sometimes containing other tissue or part of the bowel, pushes through a weak spot or opening in the strong layer of tissue (fascia) that forms the belly wall. The main types in the abdomen and groin are:

  • Inguinal hernia, in the groin, where the leg meets the abdomen;
  • Femoral hernia, at the upper thigh, close to the groin;
  • Umbilical hernia, at or near the belly button;
  • Incisional hernia, at the site of an earlier surgical cut, one type of ventral (abdominal wall) hernia.

Often there is no single clear cause. Anything that raises pressure inside the abdomen can contribute, such as heavy lifting, straining on the toilet, a long-lasting cough or constipation. Other risk factors include carrying extra weight, smoking, poor nutrition and, for some people, a family history. Incisional hernias are more likely after a large incision, and with obesity, diabetes or pregnancy.

Recognising the symptoms

The most common sign is a visible bulge or lump. It may get bigger when you cough, strain or stand, and shrink or disappear when you lie down. Other symptoms can include:

  • discomfort or pain in or around the lump, often worse when standing, straining or lifting;
  • tight, stretched skin over the lump;
  • a heavy, dragging feeling, particularly with groin hernias.

Small hernias are more likely to be painful than large ones, and a large hernia may not hurt at all. If you think you have a hernia, see a doctor so it can be properly assessed.

Warning signs that need urgent care

The main concern with a hernia is that its contents become stuck (incarcerated) and then strangulated, meaning the blood supply to the trapped tissue or bowel is cut off. A strangulated hernia is a medical emergency that needs urgent surgery.

In the UK, the NHS advises calling 999 for a possible strangulated hernia if you have:

  • very bad tummy pain that does not go away;
  • nausea or vomiting, or you cannot keep food down;
  • a hernia that is more swollen than usual and the skin over it has changed colour;
  • been unable to pass wind or poo.

The NHS also advises against driving yourself to A&E in this situation. MedlinePlus, the US National Library of Medicine's health resource, similarly advises contacting a healthcare provider right away if you have a painful hernia that cannot be pushed back in by lying down and pressing gently, nausea, vomiting or fever together with a painful hernia, or a hernia that turns red, purple, dark or discoloured. Outside the UK, treat these signs as an emergency and seek urgent care through your local emergency number.

MedlinePlus states that surgery is the only treatment that can permanently fix a hernia. Whether and when to operate depends on the type of hernia, its size and symptoms, and your general health.

Inguinal hernia

The NHS explains that an inguinal hernia may not need treatment if it is not causing symptoms. Repair is usually recommended if it causes symptoms such as pain, or to prevent the bowel becoming blocked or strangulated.

Umbilical hernia in adults

For adults, surgery is usually recommended, because an umbilical hernia is unlikely to get better on its own. Some people with other conditions, such as liver disease, may not be well enough for surgery, and their team will plan accordingly.

Incisional and other ventral hernias

Ventral hernias are common in adults and tend to get larger over time. Small hernias that cause no symptoms may simply be monitored. However, surgeons often recommend repair before a hernia becomes incarcerated, because a stuck hernia can go on to strangulate.

Surgery carries more risk for people with serious medical problems, so your surgeon will weigh the benefits of repair against your overall health.

Carrying extra weight is a recognised risk factor for hernias, and guidelines from the American Society for Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery (ASMBS) and the International Federation for the Surgery of Obesity and Metabolic Disorders (IFSO) describe obesity as a risk factor for ventral hernias in particular. For people with obesity and an abdominal wall hernia, these guidelines suggest that weight loss achieved through metabolic and bariatric surgery before the hernia repair can reduce complications after the repair. This is a decision for a specialist team and depends on the type of hernia and whether it needs urgent treatment.

After repair, keeping to a healthy weight helps lower the risk of developing another hernia. The NHS also suggests staying active, stopping smoking and seeing a doctor about a cough that does not go away.

How a hernia is repaired

Repair closes the weak spot, usually with stitches, and often with a thin sheet of mesh placed over the area to strengthen it and lower the risk of the hernia returning. The main approaches are:

  • Open surgery, using one larger cut over the hernia;
  • Keyhole (laparoscopic) surgery, using a few small cuts and a camera, sometimes with the help of a surgical robot for abdominal wall hernias. This usually means less pain and scarring, although not every hernia can be repaired this way.

The choice depends on where the hernia is, how large it is and your general health. Many repairs are done under general anaesthetic; small ventral hernias may sometimes be repaired with a spinal or epidural anaesthetic instead. An umbilical hernia repair usually takes 30 to 60 minutes.

Recovery and possible risks

Most people go home on the same day, although a very large hernia may need a stay of a couple of days. For inguinal and umbilical repairs, the NHS describes full recovery as usually taking four to six weeks. Most people need one to two weeks off work, or up to six weeks if their job involves heavy lifting, and heavy lifting is generally avoided for four to six weeks after inguinal repair.

Practical steps that help recovery include drinking plenty of fluids, eating a high-fibre diet to avoid straining, and walking several times a day, which helps prevent blood clots.

Complications are uncommon, but your surgeon will discuss:

  • wound infection, bruising or a lump at the site of the repair;
  • groin pain or numbness lasting more than three months after inguinal repair;
  • the hernia coming back, which is more likely with incisional hernias;
  • damage to nearby organs or blood vessels, which is rare;
  • blood clots in the legs or lungs.

Next steps

If you have noticed a lump in the groin or abdomen, or a hernia has already been diagnosed and you want to understand whether and when to have it repaired, a specialist review can help. You can read about our obesity and metabolic surgery team, or use our matching tool to Find my physician.

Frequently asked questions

References

  1. Hernia(opens in a new tab)NHS · Accessed November 2, 2026
  2. Inguinal hernia repair(opens in a new tab)NHS · Accessed November 2, 2026
  3. Umbilical hernia repair(opens in a new tab)NHS · Accessed November 2, 2026
  4. Hernia(opens in a new tab)MedlinePlus (U.S. National Library of Medicine) · Accessed November 2, 2026
  5. Ventral hernia repair(opens in a new tab)MedlinePlus (U.S. National Library of Medicine) · Accessed November 2, 2026
  6. Scientific evidence for the updated guidelines on indications for metabolic and bariatric surgery (IFSO/ASMBS)(opens in a new tab)American Society for Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery (ASMBS) and IFSO · Accessed November 2, 2026

This article is for general information and is not medical advice. Diagnosis and treatment decisions are made by a physician at an authorized healthcare facility.

Share this article

Weight loss & metabolic health

One-anastomosis (mini) gastric bypass: an overview

The one-anastomosis or mini gastric bypass creates a long, narrow stomach pouch joined to a loop of small intestine. Here is how it works and what to weigh up.

8 min read